Absolutely the best pizza in the BX! Ordered a slice with extra cheese & Jamaican beef patty with cheese. Loveeeeeee the slice! Always on point. Patty was ok.

In town and needed some good NY Pizza and wasn't sure where to go. Google reviews brought me there and the service and flavor brought me here. When in town again and cracking NY style pizza Nick's will be my choice.

Absolutely love Nick's pizza! I am not in the area but when I am I definitely make sure to come here! The slices are HUGE and so delicious! This pizza is worth every single cent! The staff is really nice too! Definitely a place to stop at

Not my go-to Bronx pizza place, but solid slices, classic NYC style. Every time I've went, they've been pretty generous with the cheese and slices are pretty nice-size. But at $4.50 a slice, it's definitely pricey. At $0.50 more, you're in Joe's on Carmine Street territory. The cheese, sauce and crust ratios pull the slice together pretty well and the slice hits the spot. The bottom of the slice isn't really crispy, but wasn't rubbery either. Again, to me it's just solid, standard NYC style. I got a half meatball pie the other day and it was more like a bolognese - chopped meat in a red sauce on top vs meatballs in the traditional sense, either chunks or sliced horizontally like is usually served. I wasn't really crazy about that type of meatball slice (if you consider it that), but it wasn't the worst. Those two pretty big points being the case (price and style of meatball pizza), I'd give them a three but I rate them a four star because they're open late (till 1am last I knew). So it's great for late night pizza. The guys that work there are pretty cut and dry, but nice. You pay a bit of a premium for what to me isn't really justified, but at the end of the day it's an overall good slice and open late

Still around and still the same which is a wonderful thing. Place is a time capsule with old signs and formica tables. Slices are huge. Its pricey but its excellent pizza. A type of place you rarely see these days.

This is a good pizza spot. The sausage pizza was very good. The service was good and business was clean.

Nicks is an absolute CLASSIC! Mark my words, they've been around for literal decades.They have always been a superior quality, great customer service, freshest ingredients. As a self proclaimed "Pizza Snob" I can honesty say Nicks Pizza is who developed my love and pure affection for Pizza. I hate chain pizzas, I am a huge fan of what I call "street pizza" Nicks is what I consider "street pizza". Street pizza is what I define as home style local pizzeria type pizza. Huge slices slathered in a good amount of great sauce and a great amount of mozzarella. I think what set Nick's apart from other pizzerias is the cheese! Their Mozz is some of the best around, delicious and tasty. Nicks once burned down to the ground and built right back up to resume their regular greatness. I have been going to Nick's since I was 6 years old and probably before then. I am closer to 40 then I am to 30 now, so we have lots of history between us. Anytime I'm in my hometown, I make sure I stop in and pick up a slice with mushrooms and shredded sausage. To die for! The crust is soft and warm, thin but no too thin. They are plentiful on the cheese and not stingy with toppings. They almost always toast it right. Beef patties, calzones all made fresh on premises . In the summer the kids line up around the pick up window for Italian ice's. The staff has also grown with them, keeping the same guys employed since they were 18 years old and most who are now 45-50 years old, now THAT is consistency!!

The pizza here is pretty consistent and it's good. Pros: Pizza slices are big They add a lot of toppings The prices are reasonable Right next to the train station They keep late hours Guys are cool Pretty good selection of toppings Cons: Parking sucks They don't take card (that I'm aware of) It gets very crowded Some times when it gets busy you'll get over looked